Showing posts with label snarkiness. Show all posts
Showing posts with label snarkiness. Show all posts

Monday, November 15, 2010

#15

Hitting reverse a little before wrapping things up...

Hmm nope. Not keen on Rollyo at all. At least as far as personal use goes, I would never spend time finding the right specialized search engine and then trying to use that. I don't know if other people are a lot more willing to search and play around with tangentially related resources, but I usually have a pretty good time of typing what I'm looking for into Google, and it comes up without too much effort or it doesn't (this is with regards to personal use, mind you). This to me seems like just another tool that tries to dance around getting a task done in some clever way. I admire that it's trying to give users control of their search resources but...I don't need it.

However, this isn't to say that Rollyo is useless. I can see how you might use it to build specialized engines for patrons to utilize, and build a hub of not only links but entire search engines (both ones the library compiled and ones they found on Rollyo already set for use). I do wonder if patrons would even be interested in this kind of resource or if they'd just proceed directly to Google because they are used to the results that it provides and their degree of good enough-ness. And with so many user-generated engines, how do you determine which ones are good and have a thoughtfully curated bunch of resources? Rollyo has possibilities for use in the library, certainly, but not without some hitches.

Thursday, November 4, 2010

#20

Books are still circulating quite regularly where I work, and I can't imagine that changing anytime soon. At this point it's still a matter of convenience and cost (or lack therof) for patrons. If every patron could have an ebook reader of some kind, and be able to download everything they need from the library, then they would do it. Wouldn't you? I would.
Obviously, the infrastructure (legal and otherwise) is not in place to do this yet, not to mention that ebook readers are still prohibitively expensive for a number of people (although, as with all technology, things are slowly leveling off). Will the library of the future just have shelves full of ebooks pre-loaded with entire collections? Not until they become durable enough to handle public abuse for years and / or be mended whenever the need arises.

Now, I am a huge fan of books as a physical object, but I think unless something about the presentation or formatting is particularly unique (think Mark Danielewski, or the 21 x 16 inch Kramers Ergot 7), the book is just a text vessel. It's just a matter of time before we figure out what the superior vessel is: paper or a screen.

I really enjoyed this piece from earlier this year about how good design will keep books relevant by taking advantage of their physicality, and allowing the iPad to take advantage of it's digital-ness.

This "thing" was a little thick and I didn't really want to wade through all of the different sites listed. I'll try to rip through some of it at least.

-Who on earth would want to read whole books (and by the looks of it, only public domain books) on their regular, tiny-screened phone?

-If you begin looking at / for reader's advisory sites, you will never stop. I tend to prefer sites that have actual lists rather than clever ways to try and lead the user to new books. Just give me some recommendations and send me on my way, don't make me jump through hoops for it! To look up books in a series I use Fantastic Fiction and it works quite nicely.

-I admire the motivation behind that LibriVox thing but I wonder how (or if) they vet the volunteer readers? Without some kind of screening / quality control you could end up with some really terrible audio versions of some books.

-I came across a book swap called Yours Mine Ours not too long ago, which I like because it is focused on art and design books, but I don't like it because the layout is kind of sterile and uninviting. A bit too...arty. Figures.

Sunday, October 31, 2010

#19

I think that the motivation behind "specialty" social networks is noble, but I think to a large extent it's just another example of web developers not often thinking through what exactly they are creating and just ending up with services that are redundant, poorly designed, and choked with advertisements.

I have visited last.fm a few times but never seen the necessity to join (I don't really get why I would want to share my music play counts with other folks, or what that would do...).

I wonder how many people still utilize the lowly forum / message board, and if that is considered a primal form of "social networking." I suppose Ning allows you to create a forum section on your site, but I'm talking about sites that are only a forum. (The forums on Ning sites seem pretty poorly organized anyway)
There was a forum that some acquaintances made just for their general group of friends, and that was a lot of fun (it doesn't exist any more, unfortunately). There is a forum I frequent that centers around the sort of music I enjoy, but there are sub-forums on that site to talk about other stuff that is non-music related, but of course it is with that same group of like-minded folks. I don't know, I feel like all of these different social networks (which can really be created by anybody with only a modicum of effort) are trying to pull people in by dazzling with sight and sound and screaming "This is a way to meet people who like the thing you do!" and all the while ignoring (or at least making secondary) actual dialogue and interaction with other people. It's not like I am engaging in life-altering conversations of incredible depth at the forums I browse, but I think it's more fulfilling than these sites where it just ends up being a way to share statistics.

Like robots. Social robots. "I'll show you my data if you show me yours, let's calculate our compatibility."

Thursday, October 14, 2010

#11

Previous to this prompt I have never used any social media sites to share or acquire any sort of news stories, and I don't intend to in the future. Aside from NewsVine, which seems to largely deal with, you know, actual news, other social media sites seem to largely deal with curiosities and amusements. Which is fine, but it's not news.

One thing that these sites seem to trumpet is the interactivity of it all, and the ability to comment and rate things. That's all well and good, but it takes almost no time at all for people to display their pettiness, just their utter smallness when they begin a virtual slugfest over contentious issues. NewsVine is largely news, but most of the "news" appears to be provided by partisan sources (on both sides), which makes it highly editorialized news. A viewpoint is built right into the links to many of the articles on Reddit. People distract themselves from concentrating on actual issues and actual news by either patting each other on the back for agreeing viewpoints or tearing each other apart. It's nonsense, it's a cavalcade of virtual chest-poking, it's a race to get past the news and get down to proving "insightfulness" (or displaying a loose grasp on grammar / the English language). It's the same way when people comment on articles for my hometown's local paper, the Janesville Gazette. Just a lot of people coming up with different ways to say "See, I told you so!" or "You're an idiot!" And I just realized oh my God I AM ACTING LIKE THEM RIGHT NOW NOOOOOOOOOOO.

...

I guess you can always just ignore the comments. And I guess I have difficulty understanding the impulse to try and share news stories / blog posts with nobody and then make comments on these stories and posts to a universe that doesn't know who you are.

Getting onto sort of a tangent, this is the same reason why it's hard to take reviews at Yelp or UrbanSpoon seriously: some of the people on those sites hate everything (or love everything). There is no requirement to actually be critical and fully explain your ratings, and that's not useful to me.

I would be extremely hesitant to utilize any of these sites in a library setting. I suppose you could set it up so that patrons could vote posts from your library blog up on various sites, but what good does that do you outside of your immediate user group? It would be foolish to recommend any of these sites as a decent place to get news. Even CNN.com is hardly any better than many of these sites.

Personally, I stick to BBC News and NPR for actual news because it seems to be provided with the least inflection. It can be dry and dull for sure but it's much easier to digest.

Sunday, October 10, 2010

#10

For this post I started by going back and tagging / labeling all of my previous posts. So there's that.

I had been considering signing up for delicious for a while, so I decided that this would be a good excuse to go ahead and try it. So now that I'm signed up and have my bookmarks imported in I am not really liking this at all. I am beginning to feel my oldness I think. I don't think I'll be able to stand by delicious at all, at least as far as personal use goes. Maybe it's just something in the air today, but trying to navigate through the layout on delicious is not fun at all but rather stressful. Maybe I am anti-social but I'm not interested in having another way for people to share webpages with me. Facebook does that well enough, and so does Google Reader. By and large I can find enough information about what I'm interested in on my own, thankyouverymuch. Essentially, it's too many steps and too much noise to navigate through to find what I actually want.

I think I am in agreement with Jenna that my browser's bookmarks work just fine, that I like having a sort of tiered folder structure (similar to how I navigate my computer's harddrive). I feel as thought I have a much easier time of keeping things streamlined in browser bookmarks. Everything that I want / need to check regularly comes up in and can be searched in my Reader; I don't have any serious separation anxiety when using a machine that does not have my own bookmarks. And the bookmarks in my browser can be searched as well, independent of tags.

However, I can fully see the advantages of using delicious to share bookmarks in a library setting (or other work settings for that matter). The library I work at has an account (albeit a rather sleepy one with regards to actual activity going on), and I can imagine delicious would be a great way to exchange webpages between establishments and share new and trending ideas. Setting up multiple accounts is not a bad idea for sharing bookmarks that might be of interest to different groups of users (I think Jenna mentioned College Library having it's own account, presumably other libraries on campus might have their own accounts. Or in a public library, different accounts could be established for different branches or departments).

I don't think I would recommend using delicious for serious and / or scholarly research, though. It would be really difficult to establish credibility / legitimacy of many sources. Just because it has a tag on it that might be relevant to something you were after doesn't mean you should cite that webpage. Is there anyone that has really considered using delicious to conduct scholarly research? If so, that is a crazy thing.

Casual, relatively inconsequential everyday life research, though, sure, go nuts.

Sunday, September 26, 2010

#6

letter U letter G letter H

Here I go being all sour again but the above describes how I feel about mashups and the like (at least the ones regarding photo sharing / Flickr).

I really don't find any genuine utility in almost all of these things. Being able to spell out stuff from Flickr photos is fun, it's cute, fine. But is it really useful? I don't know, maybe for someone else but not for me. And all of those applications on the Big Huge Labs site? It says it right there: they're toys. The application that turns an image into a blog header might be a time saver, I'll admit. And it is not as though this Big Huge Labs list is the end-all be-all home of mashups, but in general I think mashups are good for a bit of time killin' but not much more than that.

I couldn't properly say how a library could use some of these mashups. I do suppose it might be fun for younger kids in a school media center to play around with some of these, but I don't think a public library or certainly an academic library could get much mileage out of, you know, LOLcat generator. If someone has some great ideas and I am just not thinking hard enough about this, please, share!

Again, sorry if I sound like a jerk. Just not a fan of this stuff.

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

#3

I hate to sound like a sourpuss but I don't think I am too keen on blog searching.

In general I don't turn to blogs for news, or do blog searches for information, but for the sake of being a good sport, I tried searching for some info about an artist I like named Barry McGee on Technorati, BlogPulse, and BlogCatalog.

Technorati only yielded 7 posts, all about a recent mural McGee did on Houston Street in New York City (which I had already read about thanks to a friend posting about it on Facebook). I thought it was strange that the results didn't go any further (perhaps has something to do with the "authority rating" of the posts?). It felt like I was being blocked somehow.

The results on BlogPulse went much deeper (965 results, some in foreign languages), but there was no easy way to dig back to the older posts. The recent posts (all made within the past few weeks) were all about the same mural in New York.

A search on BlogCatalog came up with posts about a joint gallery show between McGee and Clare Rojas back at the start of the summer, which I had not heard about and was glad to see some images. There were also some results about the mural. Some results were fully unrelated ("Inspirational Country Music Award Nominees"). Unlike BlogPulse or Technorati there were no dates listed with the results. The only way I could find out when the post was from was actually clicking on the link and reading the post, so that was a bit inconvenient.

I don't generally seek out new blogs or news via blogs using a blog search. I think it's awkward and inconvenient and at this point a normal search engine will direct you to just as many if not more blogs with relevant posts. I do suppose it's an effective way to search if you're only interested in the very latest posts about something you're interested in, or if you're doing a really broad search for blogs about "cooking" or "movies" or something. Even so, a regular search engine can do this!

I come across blogs more organically in general, via suggestions from friends or links that come up on blogs I already read. Once again, I'll talk more about my info-gathering habits more when I talk about RSS.

For actual "news" news, I stick with the BBC's website and the sites for local papers.

Monday, September 13, 2010

#2

I feel like "web 2.0" and "library 2.0" are already becoming outdated phrases / ideas. Or maybe overused. I'm just tired of hearing "2.0" attached to every damn thing.

The social interactivity that defines all things "2.0" has already become such a well-worn and fully-integrated aspect of how we experience the web. It's no longer a new thing to me and it's no longer a new thing to many libraries (most libraries? I hope it's most libraries). It's just part of how I operate when using the web, and it's part of how libraries reach their user base.

Tagging has the potential to really change cataloging and searching (to some extent already has, certainly in web-specific realms (Flickr, etc)).

Wikipedia, while by no means perfect, has shown that an information hub created and rigorously edited and critiqued by its own users can result in a resource as authoritative as its old-timey counterparts.

Creative Commons licenses appear to have greatly increased due in part to the free-sharing attitudes of the "2.0" web, changing the way media is produced and consumed.

In general I think libraries are in a great position to sort of harness the huge participatory aspects of the 2.0-iverse, to heed the input of the public but to temper it with expertise, research, a critical eye, and create a positive information feedback loop. Does that make sense?

I'll talk about RSS later...

I couldn't tell you what's next, or what to call the next thing. "3.0," "Semantic Web," "Skynet," whatever. It's important to try to be aware of what's coming around the bend, no question. How is HTML5 going to impact things? I hardly know what it is but it's coming. Mobile access is just going to increase. And so on. It is as silly to try and predict a sort of "information movement" as it is to label it as soon as its clearly shown itself and then shout about it as much as you can. Does having the label change how you integrate the technology into your life or work? I don't think it should, but maybe having the stability of an obvious umbrella term lets us know what our pushing-off point to the next thing is.